Your Emails Look Great. That Might Be Why They Don’t Work.

Emails Look Great But Don't Work

Your Emails Look Great. That Might Be Why They Don’t Work.

September 4, 2025

If you're in healthcare, travel, a service-based business, or any industry where trust drives conversions, email should be one of your most profitable marketing channels. But most businesses quietly suffer from low open rates, dead lists, and disappointing ROI.

Here’s the problem:
Email marketing has changed, but most strategies haven’t.

At IMEG, we manage email campaigns for clinics, pharmacies, hotels, attractions, vacation rental managers, and service brands nationwide. We’ve seen it all. And we’ve developed a proven system to rebuild trust with inbox algorithms, boost open rates past 30 percent, and turn email into a reliable revenue engine.

Let’s break it down.

The Industry’s Broken Approach (And Why It Fails)

email marketing

Most businesses and even many agencies still run email like it’s 2015. We see it every day, and while some clients trust us to implement what works, others hold onto outdated tactics. Here's what that typically looks like:

- Blast the entire list with the same offer

Clients push for this more than you'd think. While it may feel efficient, it trains inbox algorithms to de-prioritize your messages. We always recommend segmentation.

- Use heavy graphics and branded templates

Some clients let us prioritize results. Others prefer aesthetic control. That’s their choice, but when looks win over simplicity, revenue often suffers.

- Obsess over subject lines, not sender reputation

We’ve built an advanced subject line system informed by thousands of data points. Clients who rely on it outperform those who choose headlines based on emotion or internal bias.

- Grow lists without cleaning them

Around 60 percent of our clients use our deliverability optimization platform, which includes list pruning, inbox testing, and DMARC protection. These clients consistently get better deliverability and lower overall costs.

- Chase clicks instead of quality engagement

Opens and clicks are vanity if they don’t lead to real interaction. We focus on behavior that moves the needle: replies, forwards, and true engagement.

This doesn’t just underperform. It actively damages your deliverability.

When emails are ignored, deleted, or marked as spam, inbox algorithms take note. The result? You become invisible to your audience, even if your offer is strong.

IMEG’s Email Strategy: What Makes Us Different

email marketing strategy

We don’t just "send emails." We manage deliverability, behavior-based targeting, and inbox trust like high-performance assets.

1. We Treat Your Sender Reputation Like a Credit Score

Your email performance isn’t just about content. It’s about trust. We continuously monitor and improve your sender reputation to ensure your messages land in the inbox.

2. We Prune Your List to Increase Profits, Not Just Size

While others brag about list size, we prioritize list health. Cutting out disengaged subscribers boosts your engagement rate, improves algorithm trust, and increases revenue per send.

3. We Use Segmentation That Predicts Behavior

Most marketers segment by age or gender. We segment by real actions:

  • Open history
  • Click behavior
  • Purchase or appointment activity
  • Website activity
  • And more

This behavioral segmentation turns passive readers into active buyers.

4. We Design for Deliverability, Not Just Looks

Our emails aren’t flashy most of the time. They’re effective. We strip out unnecessary graphics, write like real people, and format for mobile-first readability.

If your friend invited you to lunch with an animated, multi-buttoned email full of graphics, would it make you more likely to go? Or would it feel like an ad?

What About Beautiful, Branded Emails?

Many of our clients come to us loving polished, heavily designed templates. We understand. They want their emails to look professional.

But here’s what inbox AI sees:
"This looks like a marketing blast. Lower priority."

The irony? The emails that look less like marketing often perform better:

  • Higher inbox placement
  • More opens
  • More trust
  • More clicks

Inbox algorithms are trained to deprioritize promotional formats. That’s why we prioritize:

  • Clean, mobile-optimized layouts
  • Personal-feeling formatting
  • Clear, frictionless CTAs

Bottom line: The best-looking email is the one that gets opened, clicked, and acted on.
We design for that.

5. We Engineer Replies (The Secret Weapon)

We design emails to trigger real conversations, not just clicks. Because inbox algorithms prioritize two-way communication, replies are the strongest signal you can send that your emails matter.

What If You Have Great Open Rates but Still Low Clicks?

email marketing low clicks

We see this constantly, especially in healthcare and service industries:

  • High deliverability
  • Good open rates
  • Poor click-through rates

That usually means the email looked interesting but didn’t deliver value or clarity after the open.

Three Primary Causes:

1. The Content Doesn’t Match the Intent

The subject line creates curiosity, but the message fails to deliver a clear benefit or next step.

2. No Clear CTA

Most emails try to do too much. One email should focus on one goal. One clear action.

3. You’re Talking to Everyone, So You Convert No One

If people aren’t clicking, they may not be hearing the message meant for them.

How IMEG Fixes It:

  • Align message with audience segment
  • Use short, action-driven copy
  • Format for skimming and CTA clarity
  • Test subject lines, CTA language, layout, and timing

With IMEG, you don’t just get emails that get opened.
You get emails that convert.

The IMEG ELEVATE Framework

email marketing strategy

Our Proven Process for High-Performance Email Marketing

E.L.E.V.A.T.E. stands for:

Evaluate Your Reputation

We run a full deliverability audi, including sender score, domain health, spam triggers, and engagement history.

List Pruning and Architecture

We surgically remove unengaged contacts, rebuild list structure, and design smart segments based on behavior and lifecycle.

Engagement-Based Segmentation

We segment by actions, not assumptions. Opens, clicks, replies, and buyer behavior inform every message sent.

Value-Driven Copy

We create plain-text, high-trust messages that feel personal and drive action with no fluff, no filler, and no overdesign.

Algorithm Trust Building

We train inbox AI to trust you again with consistent engagement, clean patterns, and strategic reply tactics.

Test and Optimize Relentlessly

We A/B test subject lines, timing, copy, and CTAs to know what converts.

Expand What Works

Once we see traction, we scale the winning campaigns, re-engage dormant segments, and turn your list into a long-term profit engine.

Proven. Precise. Performance-Driven.

email marketing

Note: If you ever see an email from IMEG that looks heavily designed or follows the traditional format, understand this - it’s either a rare edge case where design is proven to perform for that audience, or a client has chosen to go against our recommendation. This is not a lack of congruency on our part. Our documented and advised strategy is always focused on performance first, not appearance.

We don’t just run email campaigns. We fix the deeper, structural issues that hold most businesses back. And we do it in industries where trust is everything.

Whether you're a private practice, tour operator, or home services brand, IMEG turns email into a scalable growth engine.

With us, you get:

  • Deliverability diagnostics and recovery
  • Behavior-based segmentation
  • Clean list architecture
  • Plain-text copywriting that converts
  • Campaigns that build trust and trigger engagement
  • Real results: better open rates, stronger sender reputation, and more revenue

Stop guessing. Start dominating the inbox.

Let’s talk about how we can turn your email list into one of your top revenue channels, just like we’ve done for hundreds of businesses nationwide. Reach out to us today.